
Discover the pros, cons, lifespan, maintenance, and ROI of Brava, metal, designer, and asphalt roofing systems.
Learn which roof delivers the best long-term value for Minnesota homeowners.
What Is the Best Roof for My Home? Comparing Brava, Metal, Designer & Asphalt Roofing.
Choosing a new roof is one of the largest investments most homeowners will ever make.
Yet many homeowners only compare price.
At Sky Armor Exteriors, we believe the better question is:
“Which roof delivers the best long-term value for my home?”
The answer depends on your goals.
Some homeowners want the lowest upfront cost. Others want maximum curb appeal, minimal maintenance, improved resale value, or a true “forever roof.”
This guide breaks down the most popular roofing systems available today and helps Minnesota homeowners understand what they are really buying.
Roofing Material Rankings: Our Overall Value Score
| Tier | Roofing Material | Best For |
|---|---|---|
| S-Tier | Brava Synthetic Slate, Shake & Barrel Tile | Luxury homes, long-term ownership, premium resale value |
| A-Tier | Standing Seam Metal Roofing | Modern homes, longevity, energy efficiency |
| A-Tier | Malarkey Windsor & Designer Roofing | Luxury appearance with lower investment |
| B-Tier | Malarkey Legacy Impact-Resistant Shingles | Performance-minded homeowners |
| C-Tier | Standard Architectural Shingles | Budget-conscious replacements |
| D-Tier | Basic 3-Tab Shingles | Lowest upfront cost |
Understanding Roofing ROI
The cheapest roof is rarely the least expensive roof.
A roof should be evaluated based on:
- Initial cost
- Expected lifespan
- Maintenance costs
- Insurance benefits
- Resale value
- Curb appeal
- Long-term ownership costs
When viewed through that lens, the rankings often change dramatically.
Option #1: Brava Synthetic Shake, Slate & Spanish Barrel Tile
The Luxury Roofing Standard
Brava roofing systems are designed for homeowners who want the appearance of natural cedar shake, slate, or clay tile without the maintenance challenges.
For luxury homes in Woodbury, Lake Elmo, Afton, North Oaks, Wayzata, Edina, Medina, Orono, and throughout Minnesota’s highest-value neighborhoods, Brava has become one of the most desirable roofing systems available.
Benefits
✅ Exceptional curb appeal
✅ Low maintenance
✅ Resistant to moisture and rot
✅ Class 4 impact resistance options
✅ Lightweight compared to natural slate
✅ Long-term performance
✅ Strong luxury resale appeal
Ideal Homeowner
Someone planning to stay in their home long-term and seeking the highest level of exterior aesthetics and performance or someone with an existing cedar shake roof who is planning to sell within the next 10 years.
Option #2: Standing Seam Metal Roofing
The Modern Forever Roof
Standing seam metal roofing continues to grow in popularity due to its clean architectural appearance and impressive lifespan.
Many lake homes, modern builds, cabins, and high-end custom homes utilize metal roofing systems.
Benefits
✅ Extremely durable
✅ Modern appearance
✅ Low maintenance
✅ Excellent snow shedding
✅ Long lifespan
Considerations
- Higher initial investment
- Architectural style matters
- Can look out of place on certain traditional homes
Ideal Homeowner
Someone seeking longevity and modern aesthetics.
Option #3: Designer Roofing Systems
Luxury Appearance Without Luxury Roofing Pricing
Designer shingles such as Malarkey Windsor provide impressive dimensional appearance for homeowners wanting a premium architectural look.
Many homeowners are surprised by how dramatic a difference a designer roof can create when compared to a standard architectural shingle.
Benefits
✅ Excellent curb appeal
✅ Lower cost than synthetic roofing
✅ Premium appearance
✅ Strong performance
Ideal Homeowner
Someone wanting a luxury appearance while maintaining a moderate budget.
Option #4: Polymer Modified Asphalt Shingles
The Smart Performance Choice
Malarkey Legacy shingles are considered one of the best-performing asphalt roofing systems available.
The rubberized polymer-modified asphalt provides enhanced flexibility and impact resistance compared to traditional shingles.
Benefits
✅ Class 4 impact resistance
✅ Better hail performance
✅ Potential insurance savings
✅ Excellent value
✅ Lower investment than designer or synthetic roofing
Ideal Homeowner
Someone seeking the best balance between performance and affordability.
Option #5: Traditional Architectural Shingles
America’s Most Common Roof
Architectural shingles remain the most popular roofing system due to affordability and simplicity.
They offer respectable performance and appearance but generally provide the lowest long-term return on investment of the systems discussed above.
Benefits
✅ Lowest investment
✅ Widely available
✅ Good appearance
Considerations
- Shorter lifespan
- Lower resale impact
- More frequent replacement cycles
Comparison Table: Which Roof Is Right For You?
| Category | Brava Synthetic | Standing Seam Metal | Malarkey Windsor | Malarkey Legacy | Standard Architectural |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Appearance | 10/10 | 9/10 | 8.5/10 | 8/10 | 7/10 |
| Longevity | 10/10 | 10/10 | 8/10 | 8/10 | 6/10 |
| Maintenance | 10/10 | 9/10 | 8/10 | 8/10 | 7/10 |
| Resale Impact | 10/10 | 9/10 | 8/10 | 7/10 | 6/10 |
| Storm Resistance | 10/10 | 9/10 | 8/10 | 10/10 | 6/10 |
| Luxury Appeal | 10/10 | 9/10 | 8/10 | 6/10 | 4/10 |
| Overall ROI | 10/10 | 9/10 | 8/10 | 9/10 | 6/10 |
Cost vs Lifetime Value
Many homeowners focus only on installation price.
The reality is that luxury roofing systems often become less expensive over decades because they require fewer repairs, fewer replacements, and significantly less maintenance.
| Roofing Type | Upfront Investment | Maintenance | Long-Term Value |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brava Synthetic | Highest | Very Low | Excellent |
| Standing Seam Metal | High | Very Low | Excellent |
| Malarkey Windsor | Moderate-High | Low | Very Good |
| Malarkey Legacy | Moderate | Low | Excellent |
| Standard Architectural | Low | Moderate | Fair |
Our Recommendation
At Sky Armor Exteriors, we generally recommend homeowners choose a roofing system based on how long they plan to own the property.
If You Want The Best Roof Available
Choose: Brava Synthetic Shake, Slate, or Barrel Tile
If You Want A Forever Roof With A Modern Look
Choose: Standing Seam Metal Roofing
If You Want Luxury Appearance Without Luxury Pricing
Choose: Malarkey Windsor Designer Shingles
If You Want Maximum Value For The Money
Choose: Malarkey Legacy Polymer-Modified Shingles
The Bottom Line
The best roof is not necessarily the cheapest roof.
The best roof is the one that aligns with your home’s architecture, your ownership timeline, and your long-term financial goals.
At Sky Armor Exteriors, we help homeowners throughout Woodbury, Lake Elmo, Afton, North Oaks, Edina, Wayzata, Medina, and the Twin Cities compare roofing systems objectively and select the roofing solution that will create the greatest value for their property.
Whether you’re investing in a luxury Brava composite roof, a modern metal roof, or a high-performance Malarkey system, our goal is the same:
To help you make a decision you will still be happy with 20 years from now.
Learn more about our roofing systems we design & install here:https://callskyarmor.com/roof-replacement-minneapolis-mn/
Learn more about our luxury roofing systems & designer roofing systems here: https://callskyarmor.com/luxury-roofing-systems/
Learn more about brava roofing systems here: https://www.bravarooftile.com/
Learn more about Malarkey Roofing Systems here: https://www.malarkeyroofing.com/products/shingles-overview/
